Not From Where You're Sitting

From the classroom

Why Good Teachers Leave (It’s Not Because They Stop Caring)

Workload, respect, autonomy and burnout, told from inside the classroom, plus what would actually make good teachers stay.

I've said goodbye to a lot of colleagues over the years.

Some retired after long, wonderful careers. Some moved schools, moved cities or took on new roles. Those goodbyes are happy ones.

But some of the goodbyes have been harder. Talented, passionate teachers who left the profession altogether. People who were brilliant with kids, who'd invested years in their training and their craft, and who decided they just couldn't keep going.

When I talk to them, they almost never say they stopped caring. Usually, it's the opposite. They cared so much that the job became unsustainable.

This article is about why good teachers leave, told from the inside.

Not because of the kids

When people imagine why teachers leave, they sometimes assume it's the students. Difficult behaviour, disrespectful kids, tough classes.

Those things can play a part. But in my experience, when teachers talk about why they left, the students are often the thing they miss most. The relationships, the funny moments, the breakthroughs. The kids are frequently the reason people stayed as long as they did.

What pushes people out tends to be everything around the kids: the workload, the paperwork, the constant change, the feeling of not being trusted or respected, the sense that no matter how hard you work, it's never enough.

Workload that doesn't fit in a life

We've talked a lot on this site about workload, so I won't repeat it all here. But it's worth saying plainly: for many teachers, the job doesn't fit in the hours they're paid for.

That's not sustainable in the long run. It might be manageable for a while, especially early in a career, when you're full of energy and don't have many other commitments. But as life gets fuller, with partners, kids, ageing parents and your own health, the extra hours start to cost more.

Eventually, some people reach a point where they have to choose between the job and the rest of their life. Many choose their life. I don't blame them.

The respect question

Respect is a tricky word, but it comes up again and again when teachers talk about the profession.

It's about how teaching is talked about in public conversation. It's about whether teachers' professional judgement is trusted, or second-guessed at every turn. It's about whether teachers are consulted on decisions that affect them, or simply told what to do. It's about the gap between how important everyone says teaching is and how teachers are actually treated.

When teachers feel respected, they can put up with a lot. When they don't, even small frustrations can feel heavier.

Autonomy and trust

One of the things that drew many of us to teaching was the chance to be creative. To design lessons, to respond to our students, to bring our own personality and expertise into the classroom.

When that autonomy shrinks, something important is lost. If every lesson has to follow a rigid script, every decision has to be justified on paper, and every new initiative is imposed without input, the job can start to feel less like a profession and more like following instructions.

I'm not arguing against all structure. Good frameworks, shared resources and clear expectations can be genuinely helpful, especially for newer teachers. But there's a difference between support and control. Teachers thrive on the first and wilt under the second.

Burnout is not a personal failing

Burnout is a word that gets used a lot. In teaching, it often looks like this: a person who used to love the job, who used to be full of ideas and energy, gradually becomes exhausted, flat and disconnected. They stop enjoying the things they used to enjoy. They start counting down to holidays. They feel like they're failing, even when they're doing a good job.

The common advice is about self-care: get enough sleep, exercise, set boundaries. That advice isn't wrong. But when the workload genuinely exceeds what's possible in a reasonable week, self-care can only do so much. You can't yoga your way out of a structural problem.

Burnout isn't a sign that a teacher is weak or not cut out for the job. Often, it's a sign that they've been carrying too much for too long.

The early-career cliff

I worry particularly about new teachers.

Early-career teachers often arrive full of enthusiasm and fresh ideas. They also arrive with a steep learning curve. Every lesson is being planned for the first time. Every behaviour situation is new. Every system has to be learnt. And they're frequently given the same, or sometimes heavier, loads as experienced colleagues.

Without good support, mentoring and a manageable workload, some new teachers burn out before they've had a chance to find their feet. That's a huge loss, both for them and for the students who would have benefited from the teachers they'd have become.

What leaving costs everyone

When a good teacher leaves, the cost isn't just theirs.

Students lose a familiar, trusted adult. Schools lose experience and relationships that took years to build. Colleagues pick up the extra load, which can push them closer to leaving too. Classes may end up with a string of casual relief teachers, which can be hard on everyone, however good those teachers are.

The system also loses all the investment that went into training and developing that teacher. And perhaps most importantly, the next generation of potential teachers is watching. When they see experienced people leaving burnt out, they may decide teaching isn't for them.

What would make people stay

I've asked a lot of colleagues what would make them stay, and the answers are remarkably consistent:

Why I'm still here

It would be dishonest to write about why teachers leave without saying that I'm still here, and that for me, the kids are the reason.

I believe a lot of teachers would say something similar. We stay because we love the work at the heart of the job. The question is whether the system around us makes it possible to keep doing that work for a whole career.

If we want good teachers to stay, we need to stop asking them to choose between the job they love and the life they need. Fix that, and I think you'd be amazed at how many would stay for good.

Next: What Parents Can See That Policymakers Can’t